Везде
S.A. Zhebelev in the System of Soviet Science (Based on New Archival Findings). Part II. 1927–1932
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
S.A. Zhebelev in the System of Soviet Science (Based on New Archival Findings). Part II. 1927–1932
Annotation
PII
S032103910010641-8-
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Vitaliy Ananiev 
ORCID: 0000-0001-7413-6339
Affiliation:
Institute of World History, RAS
St. Petersburg State University
Address: Russian Federation, St. Petersburg
Mikhail Bukharin
ORCID: 0000-0002-3590-016X
Affiliation: Institute of World History, RAS
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Edition
Volume 80 Issue 3
Pages
753-774
Abstract

The period from 1927 to 1932 was the most difficult in S.A. Zhebelev’s biography. The elections of full members of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR in 1927 were accompanied by the struggle of two groups within the Academy of Sciences: opponents of Zhebelev’s election and his supporters. The first claimed that Zhebelev violated the norms of academic ethics and tarnished his name with plagiarism. Others believed that the allegations were not made on serious grounds. After his election, academician S.A. Zhebelev had to come through another, even harder campaign which nearly led to his expulsion from the Academy of Sciences of the USSR. By 1932 Zhebelev became disillusioned with the possibility of scholarly activity in Soviet realities and directed his energies towards summing up the results of his life and studies.

Keywords
ancient history, Classical studies, science history, archives, S.A. Zhebelev, N.Ya. Marr, S.Ya. Luria, A.I. Boltunova, M.I. Maximova, scientific institutes, Academy of Sciences of the USSR
Acknowledgment
Russian Science Foundation, project no. 18-18-00367
Received
10.07.2020
Date of publication
17.09.2020
Number of purchasers
4
Views
159
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Previous versions
S032103910010641-8-1 Дата внесения правок в статью - 24.07.2020
Cite   Download pdf

References

1. Anan'ev, V.G., Bukharin, M.D. Akademik S.A. Zhebelyov i Gosudarstvennyj Ehrmitazh. Journal of Modern Russian History and Historiography 11, 43–70. 2018/

2. Anan'ev, V.G., Bukharin, M.D. Vybory S.A. Zhebelyova v dejstvitel'nye chleny AN SSSR. Journal of Modern Russian History and Historiography 13, 77–109. 2019.

3. Bezobrazov, P.V. V.G. Vasil'evskij. Vizantijskij vremennik VI/3–4, 636–652. 1899.

4. Kastanayan, E.G. Spisok pechatnykh trudov akademika Sergeya Aleksandrovicha Zhebelyova (dopolnenie k spisku trudov, izdannomu v 1926 g.). SA 7, 13–15. 1941.

5. Kokovtsov, P.K. Dlya ustanovleniya istiny. Kunstkamera. Ehtnograficheskie tetradi 1, 151–156. 1993.

6. Lur'e, Ya.S. Istoriya odnoj zhizni. SPb. 2004.

7. Nosov, N.E. (red.). Akademicheskaya arkheologiya na beregakh Nevy (ot RAIMK do IIMK RAN, 1919–2014 gg.). SPb. 2013.

8. Tunkina, I.V. M.I. Rostovtsev i Rossijskaya akademiya nauk. G.M. Bongard-Levin (red.), Skifskij roman. M., 88‒124. 1997.

9. Tunkina, I.V. «Delo» akademika S.A. Zhebelyova. Drevnij mir i my: Klassicheskoe nasledie v Evrope i Rossii. Vyp. 2, 116–161. 2000.

10. Tunkina, I.V. K istorii akademicheskikh vyborov 1929–1930 gg. Akademik S.A. Zhebelyov. Zapiska ob uchenykh trudakh D.V. Ajnalova. V sb.: A.D. Stolyar (red.), Nevskij arkheologo-istoriograficheskij sbornik: k 75-letiyu kandidata istoricheskikh nauk A.A. Formozova. SPb., 176–183. 2003.

11. Tunkina, I.V. Iz istorii akademicheskikh vyborov 1927 goda: pis'mo O.A. Dobiash-Rozhdestvenskoj M.I. Rostovtsevu. Verkhnedonskoj arkheologicheskij sbornik 7, 128–134. 2015.

12. Val'kova, O.A. Yazyk fundamental'noj nauki v Rossii. V sb.: V.M. Orel, S.S. Ilizarov (red.), Rossijskaya akademiya nauk: 275 let sluzheniya Rossii. M., 322–346. 1999.

13. Wilamowitz-Moellendorff, U. von 1932: Der Glaube der Hellenen. Bd. II. Berlin.

14. Zhebelev, S.A. 1928: J.J. Smirnov. Seminarium Kondakovianum. Recueil d’études. Archéologie. Histoire de l’Art. Études Byzantines II, 1–18.

15. Zhebelyov, S.A. Pamyati Vilamovitsa-Mellendorfa. Izvestiya AN SSSR VII/11, 1–13. 1932.

16. Zhebelyov, S.A. Ehpidavrijskaya terapevtika. Izvestiya AN SSSR. Otdelenie obschestvennykh nauk 1, 61–96. 1933.

17. Zhebelyov, S.A. Avtonekrolog. Publ. I.V. Tunkinoj, Eh.D. Frolova. VDI 2, 177–201. 1993.

18. Zhebelyov, S.A., Kovalev, S.I. Antichnyj sposob proizvodstva v istochnikakh. Literaturnye, ehpigraficheskie i papirologicheskie svidetel'stva o sotsial'no-ehkonomicheskoj istorii drevnej Gretsii, ehllinisticheskogo Vostoka i Rima. L. 1933.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate