BEADS, PENDANTS AND CHARMS: THE EVIL EYE BELIEF AMONG THE GREEK AND INDIGENOUS POPULATION OF TAURICA

Stolba, Vladimir

English

Home>Issue 2>BEADS, PENDANTS AND CHARMS: THE EVIL EYE BELIEF AMONG THE GREEK AND INDIGENOUS POPULATION OF TAURICA

BEADS, PENDANTS AND CHARMS: THE EVIL EYE BELIEF AMONG THE GREEK AND INDIGENOUS POPULATION OF TAURICA

Table of contents

Annotation Estimate Publication content

References Comments

BEADS, PENDANTS AND CHARMS: THE EVIL EYE BELIEF AMONG THE GREEK AND INDIGENOUS POPULATION OF TAURICA

Annotation

PII

S0321-03910000392-7-1

Publication type

Article

Status

Published

Authors

Vladimir Stolba Send message

Edition

Issue 2

Pages

109-128

Abstract

The article concerns the collection of beads and charms found at the necropolis of Panskoye I, the rural Greek site in the distant chora of Tauric Chersonesos. Their peculiar distribution pattern, with the majority of the finds deriving from child burials, as well as the prevalence of blue and eyed beads suggest that their role was hardly limited to serving as simple personal adornment. The archaeological and ethnographic data available indicate that these finds may be regarded as important evidence for deep-rooted religious superstitions (such as the evil-eye belief) among the ancient population of the northern Black Sea littoral. The cowrie-shell pendant which was found in child grave K39 M4 along with three glass beads furnishes further proof of this superstition. The shell, whose dome was broken off for suspension, belongs to the Monetaria (Cypraea) annulus L. species, also known as gold-ring cowrie, which is generally restricted to the Oman and East African coasts. Despite the attempts to view such shells as a symbol of womanhood, fertility, birth and wealth, the resemblance of their undersides to a half-closed human eye and the repeatedly suggested association of cowries with the vulva point towards their apotropaic purpose: to avert the influence of the evil eye. Other cowries found in the Greek and indigenous graves of the Pontic area most likely served as charms too - a function which they were supposed to have both during the lifetime of their owner and in the afterlife. The author argues that an apotropaic value might have also been tributed to a single crab's claw found in grave K43 M3 of the Panskoe I Necropolis as well as to isolated finds of unnaturally deformed iron nails. Basing his work on the closed deposits and associated finds, the author suggests a number of adjustments to the chronology of several bead varieties.

Date of publication

01.04.2009

Number of purchasers

Views

500

Readers community rating

0.0 (0 votes)

Cite Download pdf

GOST	Stolba V. BEADS, PENDANTS AND CHARMS: THE EVIL EYE BELIEF AMONG THE GREEK AND INDIGENOUS POPULATION OF TAURICA // Vestnik drevney istorii. – 2010. – Issue 2 C. 109-128 .
MLA	Stolba, Vladimir "BEADS, PENDANTS AND CHARMS: THE EVIL EYE BELIEF AMONG THE GREEK AND INDIGENOUS POPULATION OF TAURICA." Vestnik drevney istorii. 2 (2010).:109-128.
APA	Stolba V. (2010). BEADS, PENDANTS AND CHARMS: THE EVIL EYE BELIEF AMONG THE GREEK AND INDIGENOUS POPULATION OF TAURICA. Vestnik drevney istorii. no. 2, pp.109-128

References

Additional sources and materials


 Maslennikov A.A. Antichnoe svyatilische na Meotide. M., 2006;       
 Maslennikov A.A. Sel'skie svyatilischa Evropejskogo Bospora. M., 2007.                 
 Rogov E.Ya., Stolba V.F. Panskoye I. Vol. 2. The Necropolis. Aarhus, 2008.
 Hughes-Brock H. Mycenaean Beads: Gender and Social Contexts//OxfJA. 1999. 18. P. 277-278.
 Yakovenko Eh.V. Ryadovye skifskie pogrebeniya v kurganakh Vostochnogo Kryma//Drevnosti Vostochnogo Kryma (Predskifskij period i skify). Kiev, 1970. S. 125-126. Ris. 14, 3;
 Kovpanenko G.T., Yakovenko Eh.V. Skifskie kurgany na yuge Khersonschiny//Skifskie drevnosti. Kiev, 1973. S. 258;
 Terenozhkin A.I., Il'inskaya V.A., Mozolevskij B.I. Skifskie kurgany Nikopol'schiny/Tam zhe. S. 149, 163;
 oni zhe. Skifskij kurgannyj mogil'nik Gajmanovo Pole//Skify i sarmaty. Kiev, 1977. S. 159;
 Kubyshev A.I., Nikolova A.V., Polin S.V. Skifskie kurgany u s. L'vovo na Khersonschine//Drevnosti stepnoj Skifii. Kiev, 1982. S. 138.
 Eisen G. The Characteristics of Eye Beads from the Earliest Times to the Present//AJA. 1916. 20. P. 2;
 Beck H.C. Classification and Nomenclature of Beads and Pendants//Archaeologia. 1928. 77. P. 54-55;
 Deopik V.B. Klassifikatsiya bus Severnogo Kavkaza IV-V vv.//SA. 1959. №3. S. 54. Prim. 51.
 Melyukova A.I. Poselenie i mogil'nik skifskogo vremeni u s. Nikolaevka. M., 1975. S. 257. Ris. 59, 3.
 Andrukh S.I. Mogil'nik Mamaj-Gora. P. Zaporozh'e, 2001. S. 51-52. Ris. 20, 6.
 Vickers M., Kakhidze A. Pichvnari. Vol. 1. Pichvnari 1998-2002. Greeks and Colchians on the East Coast of the Black Sea. Tbilisi, 2004. P. 399. Fig. 242.
 Beck. Classification... P. 49, 66-67, gruppa XLVII A.7.d.
 Eisen. The Characteris tics... P. 3-24;
 Beck. Classification... P. 63-65;
 Deopik. Klassifikatsiya... S. 56-59;
 Alekseeva E.M. Antichnye busy Severnogo Prichernomor'ya (SAI G1-12). M., 1975. S. 51-56.
 Sr. Kiigukerman O. Glass Beads. Anatolian Glass Bead Making. The Final Traces of Three Millennia of Glass Making in the Mediterranean Region. Istanbul, 1988. P. 63.
 Kiigukerman. Glass Beads... P. 81.
 Hughes-Brock. Mycenaean Beads... P. 285-286.
 Grinsell L.V. Early Funerary Superstitions in Britain//Folklore. 1953. 64/1. P. 274.
 Dionisopoulos-Mass R. The Evil Eye and Bewitchment in a Peasant Village//The Evil Eye/Ed. S Maloney. N.Y., 1976. P. 42, 48, 50;
 Hildburgh W.L. Notes on Some Cairene Personal Amulets//Man. 1916. 16. P. 82;
 idem. Images of the Human Hand as Amulets in Spain//Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes. 1955. 18. P. 73. Not. 5;
 Westermarck E. Ritual and Belief in Morocco. Vol. 1. L., 1926. P. 439-440.
 Plin. NH. XXXII. 10 (Mayhoff): «surculi infantiae adalligati tutelam habere creduntur";
 Seligmann S. Die magischen Heil-und Schutzmittel aus der unbelebten Natur mit besonderer Beriicksichtigung der Mittel gegen den bosen Blick. Stuttgart, 1927. S. 200-205;
 Callisen S.A. The Evil Eye in Italian Art//The Art Bulletin. 1937. 19. P. 454-461;
 Hildburgh W.L. Some Spanish Amulets connected with Lactation//Folklore. 1951. 62. P. 434, 438.
 Siebers T. The Mirror of Medusa. Christchurch, 2000. P. 57-86.
 Dumas A. Le Corricolo. P., 1872. P. 178,
 Berry V. Neapolitan Charms against the Evil Eye//Folklore. 1968. 79/4. P. 250.
 John O. Über den Aberglauben des bösen Blicks bei den Alten//Berichte der Königl.-Sächsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig. 1855. 17. S. 32-40.
 Hardie M.M. The Evil Eye in Some Greek Villages of the Upper Haliakmon Valley in West Macedonia//The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland. 1923. 53. Jan.-Jun. P. 160.
 Roheim G. The Evil Eye//American Imago. 1952. 9. P. 352-55,
 Koenig S. Magical Beliefs and Practices among Galician Ukrainians//Folklore. 1937. 48. P. 67.
 Seligtapp S. Der bose Blick und Verwandtes. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte des Aberglaubens aller Zeiten und Volker. Bd 1-2. V., 1910. Bd 1. S. 11-47,
 Roberts J.M. Belief in the Evil Eye in World Perspective//The Evil Eye/Ed. S Maloney. N.Y., 1976. P. 234;
 Maloney S. Introduction//Ibid. P. xi (so ssylkoj na: Seligmann S. Die Zauberkraft des Auges und das Berufen: Ein Kapitel aus der Geschichte des Aberglaubens. Hamburg, 1922),
 Gubbins J.K. Some Observations on the Evil Eye in Modern Greece//Folklore. 1946. 57/4. P. 195-198;
 Maloney C. Don't Say «Pretty Baby» Lest You Zap It with Your Eye -The Evil Eye in South Asia//The Evil Eye. P. 146.
 Thompson M.S. Notes from Greece and the Aegean. Evil Eye Charms//Folklore. 1908. 19/4. P. 469;
 Hildburgh W.L. Some Cairene Amulets for Houses and for Horses and Donkeys//Man. 1913. 13. P. 2-3;
 Hardie. The Evil Eye.. P. 162; Coote Lake E.F. Some Notes on the Evil Eye Round the Mediterranean Basin//Folklore. 1933. 44/1. P. 93-96;
 Gubbins. Some Observations... P. 197;
 Moss L.W., Cappannari S.C. Mal'occhio, Ayin ha ra, Oculus fascinus, Judenblick: The Evil Eye Hovers Above//The Evil Eye. P. 7;
 Dionisopoulos-Mass. The Evil Eye. P. 49, 51, 57. Fig. 4, 1-2 na P. 48;
 Spooner B. The Evil Eye in the Middle East//The Evil Eye. P. 80;
 Maloney. Don't Say «Pretty Baby»... P. 119, 143;
 Lykiardopoulos A. The Evil Eye: Towards an Exhaustive Study//Folklore. 1981. 92/2. P. 226-227.
 Seligmann. Der bose Blick... Bd 1. S. 69;
 Barth F. Nomads of South Persia. L., 1961. P. 145;
 Spooner. The Evil Eye... P. 80; Moloney. Don't Say «Pretty Baby»... P. 108.
 Cp. Moss, Cappannari. Mal'occhio... P. 8-9
 Seligmann. Der bose Blick... Bd 1. S. 68-69
 Jahn. Über den Aberglauben... S. 63-66;
 Kuhnert. Fascinum//RE. 1909. Bd 6. Sp. 2010;
 Seligmann. Der böse Blick... Bd 2. S. 144-164. Abb. 85-102, 105-119, 133;
 Hildburgh W.L. Apotropaism in Greek Vase-Painting//Folklore. 1946. 57. P. 154-166;
 Steinhart M. Das Motiv des Auges in der griechischen Bildkunst. Mainz, 1995, passim.
 Seefried M. Les pendentifs en verre faconnes sur noyau du Musee National du Bardo et du Musee National de Carthage//Karthago. 1976. 17. P. 37-66;
 eadem. Glass Core Pendants Found in the Mediterranean Area//JGS. 1979. 21. P. 17-26;
 Havaernick T.E. Gesichtsperlen//MM. 1977. 18. P. 152-231.
 Tatton-Brown V. Rod-formed Glass Pendants and Beads of the 1st Millennium VS//Greek and Roman Glass in the British Museum. Vol. 1.
 Core-and Rod-Formed Vessels and Pendants and Mycenean Cast Objects. L., 1981. P. 143
 Sceglov A.N. Cult Sculpture, Altars, Sacred Vessels and Votives//Panskoye I. Vol. 1. The Monumental Building U6/Ed. L. Hannestad, V.F. Stolba, A.N. Sceglov. Aarhus, 2002. P. 217-220, 223. № G 18-19;
 Gilevich A.M. O kul'te Sabaziya v Khersonese//Drevnij Vostok i antichnaya tsivilizatsiya. L., 1989. S. 72, 128. Ris. 2.
 Sceglov. Cult Sculpture, Altars... P. 220.
 Alekseeva E.M. Antichnye busy Severnogo Prichernomor'ya (SAI G1-12). M., 1982. S. 34;                  
 Gilevich. O kul'te Sabaziya... S. 72.
 Froehner W. Catalogue des antiquites grecques et romaines, Musee de Marseille. P., 1897. P. 104. №. 285.
 Havaernick. Gesichtsperlen. P. 170;
 Seefried. Glass Core Pendants... P. 26;
 Gorokhovskaya L.P., Tsirkin Yu.B. Severnoe Prichernomor'e i Karfagen//Prichernomor'e v ehpokhu ehllinizma. Tbilisi, 1985. S. 207.
 Sceglov. Cult Sculpture, Altars... P. 227. Not. 61
 Seligmann. Der bose Blick... Bd 1. S. 190;
 Hardie. The Evil Eye... P. 161;
 Jeffreys M.D.W. Cowry, Vulva, Eye//Man. 1942. 42. P. 120;
 Hildburgh. Images of the Human Hand... P. 68;
 Roheim. The Evil Eye.... P. 352, 357;
 Dionisopoulos-Mass. The Evil Eye... P. 45;
 Teitelbaum J. The Leer and the Loom -Social Controls on Handloom Weavers//The Evil Eye/Ed. S Maloney. N.Y., 1976. P. 64;
 Spooner. The Evil Eye... P. 80;
 Maloney. Don't Say «Pretty Baby»... P. 105, 120-123;
 Lykiardopoulos. The Evil Eye.... P. 224.
 Coote Lake. Some Notes... 95.
 Hardie. The Evil Eye... P. 161;
 Hildburgh W.L. Some Spanish Amulets Connected with Lactation//Folklore. 1951. 62. P. 431;
 Roheim. The Evil Eye... P. 358; Spooner. The Evil Eye... P. 80;
 Maloney. Don't Say «Pretty Baby»... P. 105-106.
 Durham ME. The Meaning of the Cowrie: Stylized Cowrie-Pendants//Man. 1941. 41. P. 24.
 Dionisopoulos-Mass. The Evil Eye... P. 57.
 Lykiardopoulos. The Evil Eye... P. 224.
 Teitelbaum. The Leer... P. 64,
 Hardie. The Evil Eye... P. 161.
 Maloney. Don't Say «Pretty Baby»... P. 105.
 Grinsell. Early Funerary Superstitions... P. 274;
 Hildburgh. Images of the Human Hand... passim.
 Seligmann. Der bose Blick... Bd 2. S. 124 (on zhe otmechaet ispol'zovanie kleshnej dlya detskikh amuletov);
 Dionisopoulos-Mass. The Evil Eye... P. 48-50. Fig. 4,1.
 Hildburgh W.L. Notes on Some Cairene Personal Amulets//Man. 1915. 15. P. 178 i pi. N. 5,
 Thompson. Notes from Greece... P. 469;
 Hardie. The Evil Eye... P. 162;
 Spooner. The Evil Eye... P. 81;
 Moloney. Don't Say «Pretty Baby»... P. 118, 142;
 Lykiardopoulos. The Evil Eye... P. 227.
 Berry. Neapolitan Charms... P. 252
 Potts W.J. The Evil Eye//The Journal of American Folklore. 1890. 3. P. 70;
 Hauschild Th. Der bose Blick. Ideengeschichtliche und sozialpsychologische Untersuchungen. Hamburg, 1979. S. 182.
 Seligmann. Der bose Blick... Bd 1. S. 273-275;
 idem. Die magischen Heil-und Schutzmittel... S. 161-169. 3
 Stolba V.F. Kauri i prochie amulety v pogrebal'nom obryade nekropolya Panskoe I//Bosporskij fenomen. SPb., 2007. Ch. 2. S. 154-162.
 Mladenova Ya. Predmety ot st'klo i alabast'r ot nekropola na Apoloniya//Apoloniya. Sofiya, 1963. S. 310-311. № 1001. Tabl. 165),
 Grach N.L. Nekropol' Nimfeya. SPb., 1999. S. 71. Ris. 30; IV v. do n.eh.),
 Alekseeva. Antichnye busy... 1982. S. 30, tip 7a),
 Korovina A.K. Raskopki nekropolya Tiramby (1966-1970)//SGMII. 1987. 8. S. 17. Ris. 14),
 Bujskikh S.B., Nikitin V.I. Okhrannye raskopki mogil'nika IV-III vv. do n.eh. Lagernaya Kosa//Arkheolouiya. 1988. №. 63. S. 87),
 Dashevskaya O.D. Pervye issledovaniya Kul'chukskogo nekropolya//SA. 1978. № 3. S. 212, 207. Ris. 7, 5
 Bessonova S.S., Bunyatyan E.P., Gavrilyuk N.A. Aktashskij mogil'nik skifskogo vremeni v Vostochnom Krymu. Kiev, 1988. S. 151. Ris. 7,5. S. 153. Ris. 9,4. S. 173. Ris. 29, 15)
 Maslennikov A.A. Kamennye yaschiki Vostochnogo Kryma (K istorii sel'skogo naseleniya Evropejskogo Bospora v VI-I vv. do n.eh.)//Bosporskij sbornik. 1995. 8. S. 84. Ris. 8, 17. S. 99. Ris. 23, 9                  
 Kovpanenko G.T. Kurgany skifskogo vremeni u s. Medvin v Poros'e//Skify i sarmaty. Kiev, 1977. S. 46. Ris. 3,1. S. 47. Ris. 4, 17.
 Kolotukhin V.A. Gornyj Krym v ehpokhu pozdnej bronzy -nachala zheleznogo veka. Kiev, 1996. S. 148. Ris. 48, 29-31 Druzhnoe 1). 149. Ris. 49, 46. S. 150. Ris. 50, 31-32. S. 152. Ris. 52, 5. S. 153. Ris. 53,19 i 53, 32. S. 155. Ris. 55, 40 (Druzhnoe 2). S. 156. Ris. 56, 41-42 (Kapak-Tash).
 Vriuako I.V. Seashells and Nomads of the Steppes (Early Scythian Culture and Mouluscs of the Cyprea Family in Eastern Europe)//ACSS. 2007. 13. Fig. 1, 236-237).
 Murray M.A. The Meaning of the Cowrie-Shell//Man. 1939. 39. P. 167;
 idem. The Meaning of the Cowrie//Man. 1940. 40. P. 15-16;
 Sheppard T. The Meaning of the Cowrie Shell//Man. 1939. 39. P. 200;
 Driberg J.H. The Meaning of the Cowrie//Man. 1940. 40. P. 175-176;
 Durham M.E. Cowries in the Balkans//Man. 1940. 40. P. 79;
 idem. The Meaning of the Cowrie... P. 24;
 Hutton J.H. Cowries in the Naga Hills//Man. 1940. 40. P. 79;
 Jeffreys. Cowry, Vulva, Eye. P. 120; idem. Cowry and Vulva Again//Man. 1943. 43. P. 144;
 Hildburgh W.L. Cowrie Shells as Amulets in Europe//Folklore. 1942. 53/4. P. 178-195.
 Murray. The Meaning of the Cowrie-Shell. P. 167.
 Hildburgh. Cowrie Shells as Amulets in Europe, passim.
 Durham. Cowries in the Balkans. P. 79.
 Sheppard. Meaning of the Cowrie Sheel. P. 200;
 Hutton. Couries in the Naga Hills. P. 79;
 Jeffreys. Cowry, Vulva, Eye. P. 120.
 Reese D.S. Faunal Remains from the Altar of Aphrodite Ourania, Athens//Hesperia. 1989. 58. P. 68. PL 16, d-e.
 Murray. The Meaning of the Cowrie-Shell. P. 167;
 idem. The Meaning of the Cowrie. P. 16;
 Hutton. Cowries in the Naga Hills. P. 79.
 Grinsell. Early Funerary Superstitions. P. 275-276.
 Grinsell. Early Funerary Superstitions. P. 275-276.
 Elworthy F.T. The Evil Eye. An Account of this Ancient and Widespread Superstition. L., 1895. P. 255;
 Seligmann. Der bose Blick... Bd 2. S. 184;
 Roheim. The Evil Eye. P. 359.
 Fialko E.E. Skifskie kurgany u s. Novoe//Drevnejshie skotovody stepej yuga Ukrainy. Kiev, 1987. S. 172. Ris. 1,7.
 Melyukova. Poselenie i mogil'nik... S. 257. Ris. 59,26.
 Smirnov K.F. Meotskij mogil'nik u stanitsy Pashkovskoj//MIA. 1958. 85. S. 279. Ris. 5,17. S. 286. Ris. 8, 3. S. 291. Ris. 10, 7.
 Terenozhkin, Il'inskaya, Mozolevskij. Skifskij kurgannyj mogil'nik Gajmanovo Pole. S. 164. Ris. 13,20. S. 176. Ris. 28, 6. S. 184. Ris. 37, 8.
 Evdokimov G.L., Fridman M.M. Skifskie kurgany u s. Pervomaevka na Khersonschine//Skify Severnogo Prichernomor'ya. Kiev, 1987. S. 106. Ris. 17,4.
 Terenozhkin, Il'inskaya, Mozolevskij. Skifskij kurgannyj mogil'nik Gajmanovo Pole. S. 159, 155. Ris. 3, 23-24 (kurgan 4). S. 164. Ris. 13, 20 (kurgan 16). S. 186, 184. Ris. 37, 11 i 37, 16 (kurgan 27).
 Sr. Robinson D.M. Excavations at Olynthus. Pt XIII. Vases found in 1934 and 1938. Baltimor, 1950. Nos. 522A-B. PL 190, 192;
 Sparkes B.C., Talcott L. The Black and Plain Pottery of the 6th, 5th and 4th Centuries B.C. Princeton, 1970 (The Athenian Agora. XII). № 698. PL 29.
 Melyukova. Poselenie i mogil'nik... S. 74, 244. Ris. 46, 7. S. 257. Ris. 59, 26 (pogrebenie 9).
 Evdokimov, Fridman. Skifskie kurgany... S. 100-115.
 Rogov, Stolba. Panskoye I. № V 51 i V 53
 Monakhov S.Yu. Grecheskie amfory v Prichernomor'e. Kompleksy keramicheskoj tary VII-II vv. do n.eh. Saratov, 1999. S. 255-258,           
 Chetraru N., Serova N. Necropola aristocrafiei scitice de la Dubasari (sec. V-IV i.e.n.). Chiginau, 2001. P. 59. Fig. 29, 2-3.
 Vickers, Kakhidze. Pichvnari. P. 399. Fig. 242 (pogrebenie 79).
 Terenozhkin, Il'inskaya, Mozolevskij. Skifskij kurgannyj mogil'nik Gajmanovo Pole. S. 184. Ris. 37, 13.
 Terenozhkin i dr. Skifskie kurgany Nikopolytsiny. S. 130. Ris. 15, 2.
 Sr. Athenian Agora XII. № 658 i kanfarovidnyj kilik V 72 iz nekropolya Panskoe I (Rogov, Stolba. Panskoye I).
 Sr. Athenian Agora XII. № 944.
 Bessonova, Bunyatyan, Gavrilyuk. Aktashskij mogil'nik... S. 45, 174. Ris. 30.
 Mozolevskij B.N. Tovsta Mogila. Kiev, 1979. S. 122-123. Ris. 105, 12.
 Andrukh. Mogil'nik Mamaj-Gora. S. 177-180. Ris. 74, 8-9.
 Brashinskij I.B. K voprosu o datirovke kurgana Tolstaya Mogila//Arkheologicheskie issledovaniya na Ukraine, 1976-1977. Kiev, 1978. S. 67-69;
 Alekseev A.Yu. Khronografiya Evropejskoj Skifii VII-IV vv. do n.eh. SPb., 2003. S. 263-264),             
 Mozolevskij B.N., Polin S.V. Kurgany skifskogo Gerrosa IV v. do n.eh. (Babina, Vodyana i Soboleva Mogily). Kiev, 2005. S. 362-364).
 Athenian Agora XII. № 803) (sr. Olynthus XIII. PL 219. № 755;
 Ivanov T. La ceramique antique de la necropole d'Apollonia//Apollonia. Les fouilles dans la necropole d'Apollonia en 1947-1949/Ed.I. Venedikov. Sofia, 1963. PI. 115-116. Nos. 535, 542a).
 Brashinskij. K voprosu... S. 67-69;
 Mozolevskij. Tovsta Mogila. S. 22-25, 67, 194
 Kovpanenko, Yakovenko. Skifskie kurgany na yuge Khersonschiny. S. 260. Ris. 3,12.
 Petrenko. Pravoberezh'e Srednego Pridneprov'ya... S. 82. Tabl. 23,13;
 Kovpanenko, Bessonova, Skoryj. Pamyatniki skifskoj ehpokhi... S. 130, 132. Ris. 41, 34.
 Petrenko. Pravoberezh'e Srednego Pridneprov'ya... S. 135. Tabl. 13, 6).
 Sr. Subbotin, Ostroverkhoe, Okhotnikov, Redina. Skifskie drevnosti... S. 41. Ris. 16, 7-8
 Alekseeva. Antichnye busy... 1978. S. 74. Tabl. 34, 40.
 Sr. gruppu XXII V.2.' u Beka (Beck. Classification... P. 23. Fig. 20).
 Smirnov. Meotskij mogil'nik... S. 288-290
 Smirnov K.F. Sarmaty na Ileke. M., 1975. S. 131-133. Ris. 31B.1-2.               
 Popovic P. Les perles de verre en forme de vase ou d'amphore sur l'espace entre la mer Adriatique et le Danube//Starinar. 1997. 48. P. 165-171.
 Dlya distributsii nakhodok sm. kartu (R. 169. Fig. 2).
 Melyukova A.I. Naselenie Nizhnego Podnestrov'ya v IV-II vv. do n.eh.//Problemy skifskoj arkheologii. M., 1971. S. 52. Ris. 7, 7;
 ona zhe. Poselenie i mogil'nik... S. 257. Ris. 59,20.
 Grakov. Skifskie pogrebeniya... S. 107. Ris. 6, 10b (kurgan 2, mog. 2);
 Andrukh. Mogil'nik Mamaj-Gora. S. 81-82. Ris. 34, 19 (kurgan 67, pogr. 7).
 Alekseeva E.M. Klassifikatsiya antichnykh bus//Statistiko-kombinatornye metody v arkheologii. M., 1970. S. 76. Ris. 4, 12 (Beglitskij nekropol').             
 Koltukhov S.G. Kurgan IV Akkajskogo (Belogorskogo) kurgannogo mogil'nika//Drevnosti Bospora. 2006. 9. S. 239, 259. Ris. 17, 11.
 Nesmotrya na utverzhdenie A.S. Ostroverkhova (Fayansovye i steklyannye busy v Skifii i Sarmatii//VDI. 1985. № 3. S. 100),
 Petrenko. Pravoberezh'e Srednego Pridneprov'ya... Tabl. 23, 16)
 Pamyatniki skifskoj ehpokhi... S. 312. № 153
 Redina E.F. Skifskij mogil'nik u s. Nedelkovo na severe Odesskoj oblasti//Stratum plus. 1999. 3. S. 77, 79. Ris. 3, 7
 Alekseeva. Antichnye busy... 1978. S. 74.
 Ostroverkhoe. Fayansovye i steklyannye busy... S. 100.
 Kubyshev, Nikolova, Polin. Skifskie kurgany... S. 133-140. Ris. 6, 9 i 6,21.
 Athenian Agora XII. № 608-609.
 Rogov, Stolba. Panskoye I. № V 57)
 Kovpanenko, Yakovenko. Skifskie kurgany na yuge Khersonschiny. S. 260. Ris. 3, 8. S. 262. Ris. 6.
 Kac V.I. A New Chronology for the Ceramic Stamps of Herakleia Pontike//The Cauldron of Ariantas. Studies presented to A.N. Sceglov on the Occasion of his 70th Birthday/Ed. P.O. Bilde, J.M. Højte, V.F. Stolba. Aarhus, 2003. P. 275-277)     
 Rogov, Stolba. Panskoye I. № Ab 40)
 Terenozhkin A.I., Mozolevskij B.N. Melitopol'skij kurgan. Kiev, 1988. S. 78. № 20d. S. 82-84. Ris. 85; 86, 1; 87. S. 105. Ris. 117.1p. S. 108-109. № 89p. Ris. 119. S. 110. № 90l. S. 111-113. Ris. 121-123.
 Grecheskie am fory v Prichernomor'e... S. 402-405)
 Alekseev. Khronografiya... S. 265-266
 Terenozhkin, Mozolevskij. Melitopol'skij kurgan. S. 80. Ris. 83, 2. S. 116. Ris. 126),
 Athenian Agora XII. № 558-560
 Terenozhkin, Mozolevskij. Melitopol'skij kurgan. S. 80. Ris. 83,5. S. 115. Ris. 125
 sr. Moore M. Attic Red-Figured and White-Ground Pottery. Princeton, 1997 (The Athenian Agora. XXX). № 1121, 1135).
 Yakovenko Eh.V. «Lavka yuvelira» na Elizavetivs'komu gorodischi//Arkheologiya. 1987. №60. S. 83-91.
 Tam zhe. S. 87. Ris. 3,1-3;
 Marcenko K.K., Zitnikov V.G., Kopylov V.P. Die Siedlung Elizavetovka am Don. Moskau, 2000 (Pontus Septentrionalis II. Tanais 2). Abb. 64, 3 i 65, 6.
 Yakovenko. «Lavka yuvelira». S. 87. Ris. 3,4;
 Marcenko, Zitnikov, Kopylov. Die Siedlung Elizavetovka... Abb. 48, 4.
 Robinson. Excavations Olynthus... XIII. P. 322-323. № 638. P. 395. № 956A, 956B. PI. 221.
 Brashinskij I.B. Grecheskij keramicheskij import na Nizhnem Donu v V-III vv. do n.eh. L., 1980. S. 141. № 241. Tabl. 19, 21.
 Yakovenko. «Lavka yuvelira»... S. 85
 Tam zhe. S. 88. Ris. 4, 1-3.
 Rogov E.Ya. Glass Objects//Panskoye I. Vol. 1. The Monumental Building U6/Ed.L. Hannestad, V.F. Stolba, A.N. Sceglov. Aarhus, 2002. P. 277. № N 9-11.
 Hannestad L., Stolba V.F., Sceglov A.N. Conclusion//Panskoye I. Vol. 1... P. 281;
 Hannestad L. The Dating of the Monumental Building U6 at Panskoye I//Chronologies of the Black Sea Area in the Period s 400-100 VS/Ed. V.F. Stolba, L. Hannestad. Aarhus, 2005. P. 180.
 Eisen. The Characteristics... P. 2 (s literaturoj);
 Coote Lake. Some Notes... P. 96;
 Davison C.C., Clark J.D. Transvaal Heirloom Beads and Rhodesian Archaeological Sites//African Studies. 1976. 35. P. 123-137.
 Lillios K.T. Objects of Memory: The Ethnography and Archaeology of Heirlooms//Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory. 1999. 6. P. 235-262.             
 Popovic. Les perles de verre... P. 166-168. Fig. 1.
 Ostroverkhov A.S. Steklo i fayans kak istochnik dlya izucheniya ehkonomicheskikh svyazej i ideologicheskikh vozzrenij skifov v V-III vv. do n.eh.//Kimmerijtsy i skify. Tezisy dokladov Vsesoyuznogo seminara, posvyaschennogo pamyati A.I.Terenozhkina. Kirovograd, 1987. Ch. 2. S. 39.
 Ostroverkhov. Fayansovye i steklyannye busy... S. 100-101;
 on zhe. Steklo i fayans kak istochnik... S. 39.
 On zhe. Antichna sklorobna majsternya na Yagorlits'komu poselenni//Arkheologiya. 1978. № 25. S. 41-49;
 on zhe. Drevnejshee antichnoe proizvodstvo steklyannykh bus v Severnom Prichernomor'e//SA. 1981. № 4. S. 214-228.
 On zhe. Torgovlya busami v ehllinisticheskoj Ol'vii//Tezisy dokladov Krymskoj nauchnoj konferentsii «Problemy antichnoj kul'tury», 19-24 sentyabrya 1988 g. Simferopol', 1988. S. 262-263
 On zhe. Fayansovye i steklyannye busy... S. 101;
 Yakovenko. Ryadovye skifskie pogrebeniya... S. 83-91;
 Marcenko, Zitnikov, Kopylov. Die Siedlung Elizavetovka... S. 112-115. Abb. 48,1-3.
 Trejster M.Yu. Garnitur ukrashenij iz pogrebeniya 1 Starshego Trekhbratnego kurgana//Greki i varvary na Bospore Kimmerijskom VII-I vv. do n.eh. Materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii, Taman' (Rossiya), oktyabr' 2000. SPb., 2006. S. 175. Ris. 20)
 Yakovenko. Ryadovye skifskie pogrebeniya... S. 125-126. Ris. 14, 3)
 Skoryj S.A. Skifskij kurgan s katakombami v Severnom Krymu//Drevnosti stepnoj Skifii. Kiev, 1982. S. 235. Ris. 5, 4; IV v. do n.eh.
 Leskov A.M., Beglova E.A., Ksenofontova I.V., Ehrlikh V.R. Meoty Zakuban'ya v seredine VI-nachale III veka do n.eh. Nekropoli u aula Ulyap. Pogrebal'nye kompleksy. M., 2005. S. 177    
 Subbotin L.V., Ostroverkhov A.S., Okhotnikov S.B., Redina E.F. Skifskie drevnosti Dnestro-Dunajskogo mezhdurech'ya. Kiev, 1992. S. 45. Ris. 20,5-9
 Kovpanenko G.T., Bessonova S.S., Skoryj S.A. Pamyatniki skifskoj ehpokhi Dneprovskogo Lesostepnogo Pravoberezh'ya (Kievo-Cherkasskij region). Kiev, 1989. S. 130. Ris. 41, 42; IV v. do n.eh.),
 Grakov B.N. Skifskie pogrebeniya na Nikopol'skom kurgannom pole//MIA. 1962. 115. S. 93
 Terenozhkin A.I., Il'inskaya V.A., Chernenko E.V., Mozolevskij B.N. Skifskie kurgany Nikopolytsiny//Skifskie drevnosti. Kiev, 1973. S. 130. Ris. 15, 2
 Andrukh. Mogil'nik Mamaj-Gora. S. 133-134. Ris. 54, 8. S. 162. Ris. 67, 6; IV v. do n.eh.
 Fridman M.I. Skifskie kurgany u s. Dudchany na Khersonschine//Drevnejshie skotovody stepej yuga Ukrainy. Kiev, 1987. S. 167. Ris. 5,5; IV v. do n.eh.)
 Evdokimov G.L., Fridman M.I. Kurgany skifskogo vremeni u s. Pervomaevka na Khersonschine//Kurgany stepnoj Skifii. Kiev, 1991. S. 77. Ris. 4, 4
 Petrenko V.G. Pravoberezh'e Srednego Pridneprov'ya v V-IV vv. do n.eh. (SAI D1-4). M., 1967. S. 34. Tabl. 23, 21a;     
 Il'inskaya V.A. Skify dneprovskogo lesostepnogo Levoberezh'ya (kurgany Posul'ya). Kiev, 1968. S. 32, 39.
 Galanina L.K. Skifskie drevnosti Podneprov'ya (Ehrmitazhnaya kollektsiya N.E. Brandenburga) (SAI D1-33). M., 1977. S. 29. Tabl. 14, 11;
 Obychnyj Grinsell. Early Funerary Superstitions... P. 274;
 Obychnyj Driberg. Meaning of the Cowrie. P. 175;

Comments

No posts found

Write a review

Translate

References

Additional sources and materials

Comments

Via social network